Short answer
In most cases, filling with a garden hose from your own tap is the cheaper option, because you pay only for the water. A delivery truck adds a delivery fee on top of the water, but it is much faster and may be the practical choice when a hose is slow, your supply is restricted or you are in a drought.
Costs vary a lot by location, so the best approach is to work out your own numbers.
What you pay for either way
Both methods need water, and you pay for it somewhere:
- Hose: you pay your utility’s water rate, or the cost of pumping if you are on a well.
- Truck: you pay the supplier’s price, which includes the water, the driver and the truck’s time.
First, estimate how much water you need. For a rectangular pool, multiply length x width x average depth x 7.5 for gallons. For a round pool, multiply diameter x diameter x average depth x 5.9. A pool with a shallow and deep end needs the average depth, not the deepest point.
Filling with a hose
Cost: gallons needed (in thousands) x your rate per thousand gallons. Rates differ widely between areas, and some tiered rates climb as your monthly usage goes up, so a big fill can land in a higher tier. Your water bill shows the current rate.
Time: a garden hose delivers limited flow. As an illustration, if a hose gave 5 gallons per minute, a 10,000 gallon pool would need over 30 hours. Large pools can take days.
Other considerations:
- Water pressure for the rest of the household may dip while you fill.
- You need to watch the hose, and stop it before the pool overflows.
- Some utilities restrict outdoor water use or ask you to notify them.
Filling with a water truck
Cost: one delivery load plus any extra fees. A guide from Pool Calculator lists examples around $150 to $350 per load in some US regions, with tanks ranging from roughly 1,200 to 6,000 gallons. Treat those as ballpark figures, not quotes. Prices depend on distance, load size, season and the type of water.
Time: a delivery can fill a medium-sized pool in a few hours, rather than days.
Other considerations:
- Ask whether the water is potable or municipal, and whether the tank is clean. Stainless steel tanks are often preferred.
- Some suppliers offer pre-chlorinated water, but some municipalities do not allow it. You still need to test the water afterward.
- You can often fill a pool without being home, depending on the company.
- For a big pool you may need more than one load, and some suppliers discount repeat loads.
Cost comparison
Here is an example with made-up numbers, just to show the method. Say your pool needs 15,000 gallons and your utility charges $5 per thousand gallons. A hose fill would cost about $75. If a supplier charged $300 for each 6,000 gallon load, you would need three loads, or about $900. Even if your real numbers are different, the pattern is common: delivery is generally the more expensive route, while the hose is slower.
Where a truck can come out ahead:
- your municipal water rates are unusually high or tiered steeply;
- your well cannot keep up and runs dry or muddy;
- local restrictions limit hose use;
- your time or utility bill constraints matter more than the delivery fee.
Sewer charges and credits
Many utilities base the sewer part of your bill on how much water you use. A pool fill may be billed as if it all went down the drain, which can raise the cost a lot. Some utilities let pool owners register or ask for a credit or exemption, and a forum discussion we reviewed mentions this kind of arrangement. Call your water company before you fill, and ask:
- Is there a sewer charge on a pool fill, and can it be waived or credited?
- Do I need to register the pool or notify you?
- Are there restrictions on outdoor water use or filling times?
Cheapest ways to fill
- Use well water, if you have a well with enough capacity. It often costs less than metered city water, though it may need extra testing and treatment for iron or minerals.
- Ask for a sewer credit before you fill.
- Fill slowly with a hose when speed does not matter.
- Do a partial refill where possible. See how often a pool needs to be drained for why a partial change is often enough.
- Cut down future fills. Use a pool cover and fix leaks so you are not paying to replace lost water. Our guide to draining and refilling a pool explains how to check for water loss.
After filling
Whichever way the water arrives, test it. Fresh water, including delivered or pre-chlorinated water, may need pH, alkalinity, calcium hardness and sanitizer adjustments before it is safe to swim in. Do not skip this step, since the numbers in fresh water are not always what you expect.