The short answer
Often not by much, and sometimes not at all. A saltwater pool usually costs more to set up and less to feed with chemicals. The salt cell then has to be replaced every few years, which can erase much of the chemical savings. Published cost comparisons disagree. Some show salt coming out cheaper over several years, and others show it coming out slightly more expensive. The real answer depends on your pool size, climate, equipment and how long you keep the pool.
Upfront cost
A salt system adds the price of the generator and installation, whether you are building a new pool or converting an existing one. Sources cite figures anywhere from a few hundred dollars for small systems to a few thousand for larger installations with professional work. For a new pool, you may also pay for compatible equipment such as salt-rated heaters or fixtures. A chlorine pool has the lowest entry cost, since it needs no generator. Get a current quote for your pool, since prices vary by brand and region.
Chemical costs
This is where salt usually saves money. Instead of buying chlorine regularly, you buy pool salt, which is inexpensive and needed in smaller amounts once the pool is up to level. Some sources estimate annual chemical spending for a salt pool at about a hundred to a couple of hundred dollars, against several hundred or more for chlorine. Not every analysis agrees: one regional pool service puts total monthly chemistry slightly higher for salt, because pH adjusters are used more often and cells need to be maintained. Keep in mind that a salt pool is not free of chemicals. You still need acid, stabilizer, test supplies and occasional shock. See our saltwater pool care guide for what to stock.
Salt cell replacement
The cell is the main recurring cost. Cells commonly last about three to seven years, and replacement prices cited range from a few hundred dollars to well over a thousand depending on the brand and the size. See how long a salt cell lasts for what affects the timing. Spreading the price over the cell’s life gives an annual figure you can add to your running costs. Buying a larger cell than the minimum often costs more up front, but may help it last longer.
Electricity and equipment wear
Salt generators draw some electricity when the pump runs, which adds a little to your bill. Salt can also be harder on some metal fixtures, natural stone and certain equipment, particularly in coastal areas. Where it applies, that can mean replacing items sooner or buying salt-rated parts. See sacrificial anodes for salt water pools for one way owners guard against corrosion.
A simple way to compare your own numbers
Add up, over the number of years you plan to keep the pool:
- Chlorine pool: annual chlorine, shock, algaecide and pH chemicals, times years.
- Saltwater pool: generator price and installation, plus annual salt and pH chemicals, plus electricity, plus one or more cell replacements, plus any equipment upgrades.
Subtract one total from the other. If the pool is small, the climate is mild and you use it seasonally, chlorine may come out ahead. If it is larger, heavily used or in a long swim season, salt gets more competitive.
When salt tends to pay off
Salt tends to make financial sense when you plan to keep the pool for many years, dislike handling chlorine, and your equipment suits salt. If you are an above ground owner, see saltwater vs chlorine for above ground pools. If you decide to convert, follow how to convert a chlorine pool to saltwater.