Saltwater Pools

Saltwater vs Chlorine for Above Ground Pools

Saltwater or chlorine for an above ground pool? Compare cost, upkeep, water feel and corrosion risk, plus when each option makes the most sense.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. How each system works
  3. Cost compared
  4. Water feel and comfort
  5. Maintenance compared
  6. Above ground specifics
  7. Which to choose

The short answer

Both kinds of pool are sanitized by chlorine. The difference is where it comes from. In a traditional pool you add chlorine yourself as tablets, liquid or granules. In a saltwater pool, a salt chlorine generator makes chlorine from dissolved salt. For an above ground pool, saltwater is mostly a question of convenience and water feel against upfront cost and material compatibility. Neither is clearly better for everyone.

How each system works

Traditional chlorine. You test the water and add chlorine on a regular schedule, often using floating dispensers, feeders or liquid chlorine. You control exactly how much goes in, but you handle and store the chemicals.

Saltwater. You add pool salt once, then a generator connected to your pump and plumbing turns that salt into chlorine whenever the pump runs. The chlorine returns to salt after it sanitizes, so the cycle repeats. You still test the water and balance pH. The process is described in more detail in our saltwater pool care guide.

Cost compared

Saltwater generally costs more upfront because you buy a generator and, for a new pool, may pay extra for compatible components. Estimates vary widely by product and region, so get current prices before deciding. Ongoing chemical spending is usually lower with salt, since a bag of salt is inexpensive compared with a season of chlorine.

Against that, the salt cell is a wear item that needs replacing after several years, and the generator adds a little to your electricity use. Over a few years, the total can end up close to a well-managed chlorine pool. Our article on whether saltwater pools are more expensive to maintain than chlorine goes deeper, and how long a salt cell lasts helps you plan for replacement.

Water feel and comfort

Many swimmers describe saltwater as softer and less irritating, with less of the strong chemical smell. That smell comes largely from chloramines, which form when chlorine reacts with sweat, oils and other organic matter, so it can reflect water that needs attention more than how much chlorine is present. A generator that produces chlorine steadily can help keep levels more even, though a poorly balanced pool of either type can still irritate eyes and skin.

Maintenance compared

  • Chlorine pool: frequent testing, regular dosing, and periodic shocking.
  • Saltwater pool: regular testing of pH and chlorine, occasional salt testing, and cleaning scale from the cell. pH tends to drift upward and often needs acid.

Saltwater is lower effort on a day-to-day basis, not maintenance-free.

Above ground specifics

Corrosion is the main extra consideration. Salt water can corrode exposed metal over time. Many above ground pools have steel walls, rails or other metal components, so check the manufacturer’s guidance and warranty before adding salt. Some resin or hybrid-frame pools are designed with salt in mind, and some manufacturers sell salt systems intended for their own pools. Pay attention to ladders, light housings, pump parts and any metal that touches the water. A sacrificial anode is one way some owners protect certain metal parts.

Pool volume matters as well. Generators are rated by gallons, so choose one suited to your pool and see choosing a salt water system for an above ground pool for options. If you already have a chlorine pool, the steps in how to convert a chlorine pool to saltwater apply.

Which to choose

Saltwater may suit you if you plan to keep the pool for several seasons, dislike handling chlorine, and your pool’s materials are compatible with salt. Traditional chlorine may suit you if you want the lowest purchase price, have a steel-walled pool whose warranty does not cover salt, or only use the pool occasionally. If you want to avoid chlorine even more, see chlorine-free pool systems and mineral purifiers, though most of these still rely on some sanitizer.

The complete guide to saltwater pools

Saltwater Pool Care: Salt, pH and Shock
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →